Mold 100 % AG Charlottenburg 203 C 607/06 Berlin 09.07.2007 Severe Health hazard from toxic mold spores; children needed emergency treatment Letter Heating / Hot Water 100 % LG Berlin 65 S 70/92 Berlin 20.10.1992 Severe Total gas supply failure Sep–Feb Letter Heating / Hot Water 100 % LG Hamburg 7 O 80/74 Hamburg 15.05.1975 Severe Oil heating failure during the winter months Letter Water Damage / Moisture 100 % AG Potsdam 26 C 533/93 Brandenburg 15.06.1995 Severe Damp walls and ceilings, rats, mold; apartment uninhabitable Letter Water Damage / Moisture 100 % AG Schöneberg 109 C 256/07 Berlin 10.04.2008 Severe Leaking water meter; 50 dB(A) drying machines made the apartment uninhabitable Letter Water Damage / Moisture 100 % AG Köln 227 C 6/17 North Rhine-Westphalia 07.07.2020 Severe Apartment uninhabitable after water damage from corroded heating pipes; 5% afterwards for a musty smell Letter Water Damage / Moisture 100 % AG Tempelhof-Kreuzberg 16 C 289/18 Berlin 02.05.2019 Severe Ceilings, walls and floors of every room soaked and moldy; water comes in whenever it rains Letter Power / Gas Outage 100 % LG Berlin 65 S 70/92 Berlin 20.10.1992 Severe Total gas supply failure Sep–Feb Letter Power / Gas Outage 100 % AG Neukölln 15 C 23/87 Berlin 20.10.1987 Severe Total electrical failure after a cable fire; no light, hot water or stove Letter Pests / Vermin 100 % AG Aachen 80 C 569/97 North Rhine-Westphalia 03.12.1998 Severe Khapra beetle infestation; apartment uninhabitable because of harmful pest-control chemicals (June–Oct 1996) Letter Pests / Vermin 100 % AG Brandenburg a.d. Havel 32 C 520/00 Brandenburg 06.08.2001 Severe Mouse plague: up to 10 mice in the living room at once Letter Other 100 % LG Würzburg 44 S 119/23 Bavaria 10.05.2023 Severe Apartment uninhabitable after a kitchen fire the tenant did not cause through gross negligence; the landlord's building insurance applies Letter Other 100 % LG Dresden 4 S 73/10 Saxony 25.02.2011 Severe Weakly bound asbestos constantly releases fibers (top remediation urgency); apartment unfit to live in Letter Other 100 % LG Berlin 65 S 117/02 Berlin 30.08.2004 Severe Extremely high levels of carcinogenic PAHs in the indoor air; apartment uninhabitable Letter Heating / Hot Water 85 % AG Nürnberg 16 C 127/16 Bavaria 22.03.2017 Severe Gas supply out for 20 months: no heating, hot water or cooking; 85% Oct–Apr, 60% in the other months Letter Power / Gas Outage 85 % AG Nürnberg 16 C 127/16 Bavaria 22.03.2017 Severe Total gas supply failure: no heating, no hot water, no cooking (85% in winter) Letter Mold 80 % LG Berlin 65 S 205/89 Berlin 08.01.1991 Severe Entire apartment permanently damp, musty and infested with mold Letter Water Damage / Moisture 80 % LG Köln 1 S 176/11 North Rhine-Westphalia 29.03.2012 Severe Mold in a studio apartment; two drying machines, hardly any room to move Letter Noise 80 % LG Hamburg 307 S 135/95 Hamburg 11.01.1996 Severe Landlord converts the attic; apartment below unusable Letter Mold 75 % LG Köln 9 S 25/00 North Rhine-Westphalia 15.11.2000 Severe Mold in every room of a newly built apartment at first occupancy Letter Heating / Hot Water 75 % LG Berlin 64 S 291/91 Berlin 10.01.1992 Severe Total heating failure Nov–Feb Letter Heating / Hot Water 70 % AG Charlottenburg 216 C 7/13 Berlin 07.06.2013 Severe Heating completely out Oct–Dec during conversion to an apartment gas heating system Letter Heating / Hot Water 70 % LG Berlin 61 S 37/02 Berlin 29.07.2002 Severe Heating failure during the heating season Oct–Apr Letter Water Damage / Moisture 60 % AG Bad Vilbel 3b C 52/96 Hesse 20.09.1996 Severe Damp rising from the floor, wallpaper peeling off, floor tiles cracked Letter Pests / Vermin 60 % AG Stuttgart 35 C 5509/19 Baden-Württemberg 30.03.2021 Severe Severe bedbug infestation; bringing them in with luggage counts as normal use of the apartment Letter Mold 50 % LG Hamburg 307 S 144/07 Hamburg 31.01.2008 Severe Severe mold in the living room; 60% of the living space affected Letter Heating / Hot Water 50 % LG Bonn 6 S 396/81 North Rhine-Westphalia 02.11.1981 Severe Heating broken from November and again in February and April; apartment could not be heated Letter Heating / Hot Water 50 % AG Mitte 20 C 318/21 Berlin 16.05.2022 Severe Gas supply cut off, no heating or hot water; staggered: Oct 20%, Nov/Mar 30%, Dec–Feb 50% Letter Water Damage / Moisture 50 % AG Leverkusen 23 C 471/76 North Rhine-Westphalia 18.04.1979 Severe Carpet completely soaked; water dripping through the ceiling Letter Noise 50 % AG Braunschweig 113 C 168/89 (9) Lower Saxony 03.08.1989 Severe Excessively loud music from a neighbor; glasses vibrating in the cupboard Letter Other 50 % AG Bielefeld 408 C 180/24 North Rhine-Westphalia 11.09.2025 Severe Landlord secretly kept a key and entered the apartment without permission Letter Noise 40 % LG Berlin 67 S 342/01 Berlin 05.08.2002 Severe Noise from two bars on the ground floor from 10 pm to 4 am Letter Noise 35 % LG Hamburg 333 S 13/01 Hamburg 05.07.2001 Severe Major construction site (Elbe tunnel) about 50 m away, noise barrier 10 m in front of the windows Letter Mold 30 % AG Köln 206 C 20/18 North Rhine-Westphalia 10.05.2019 Moderate Mold from thermal bridges in the kitchen, bedroom and children's room; landlord did not disprove a structural defect Letter Heating / Hot Water 30 % AG Görlitz 1 C 1320/96 Saxony 03.11.1997 Moderate Apartment can only be heated to 16–18 °C Letter Heating / Hot Water 30 % AG Karlsruhe 3 C 294/23 Baden-Württemberg 09.08.2023 Moderate Radiator in the largest room broken all winter; 5% afterwards Letter Water Damage / Moisture 30 % AG Bochum 5 C 668/78 North Rhine-Westphalia 28.11.1978 Severe Living room unusable due to water damage Letter Water Damage / Moisture 30 % AG Kiel 13 C 9/80 Schleswig-Holstein 26.06.1980 Severe Water dripping through the ceiling Letter Noise 30 % AG Charlottenburg 213 C 322/09 Berlin 08.09.2010 Severe Heavy noise from an expanded guesthouse (slamming doors, bathroom use at night) Letter Noise 30 % AG Schöneberg 17 C 96/21 Berlin 08.02.2022 Moderate Attic conversion: scaffolding, covered windows, construction noise, plaster falling from the ceiling Letter Noise 30 % AG Schöneberg 5 C 1/20 Berlin 10.02.2022 Moderate Extensive construction work in the building: vibrations, noise, scaffolding, dust and solvent smell; later 20% Letter Mold 25 % LG Berlin 67 S 358/20 Berlin 06.04.2021 Moderate Mold because the landlord did not give adequate ventilation instructions Letter Heating / Hot Water 25 % AG Frankfurt a.M. 33 C 588/11-76 Hesse 28.10.2011 Moderate Repeated heating failure over the Christmas holidays Letter Heating / Hot Water 25 % AG Hamburg 46 C 191/72 Hamburg 22.03.1973 Moderate Heating out for 20 days in October Letter Water Damage / Moisture 25 % AG Osnabrück 14 C 231/94 Lower Saxony 31.03.1995 Moderate Rainwater entering through the chimney top; water stains on the walls; leaking windows Letter Water Damage / Moisture 25 % AG Wedding 14 C 355/12 Berlin 10.02.2014 Moderate Kitchen of a 4-room apartment unusable after water damage Letter Noise 25 % LG Berlin 67 S 251/13 Berlin 26.09.2013 Moderate Long-term construction noise from a full building refurbishment Letter Pests / Vermin 25 % AG Bremen 25 C 0118/01 Bremen 06.12.2001 Moderate Severe moth infestation Letter Other 25 % AG Potsdam 26 C 406/94 Brandenburg 09.03.1995 Severe Apartment door cannot be locked; security and insurance risk Letter Other 25 % AG Gelsenkirchen 428 C 498/15 North Rhine-Westphalia 01.12.2016 Moderate Damaged bathroom and drafty, poorly closing windows (combined rate) Letter Mold 20 % AG Osnabrück 48 C 31/12 (5) Lower Saxony 10.10.2013 Moderate Damp and mold in the living room, bedroom and kitchen with a musty smell Letter Heating / Hot Water 20 % AG Köln 152 C 1249/74 North Rhine-Westphalia 06.12.1976 Minor Room temperature only 16–18 °C Letter Heating / Hot Water 20 % LG Hannover 11 S 296/79 Lower Saxony 19.12.1979 Moderate Bedroom could not be heated in February Letter Water Damage / Moisture 20 % LG Berlin 64 S 71/89 Berlin 30.05.1989 Moderate Soaked wall in the living room, water stains on the ceiling of the bay-window room Letter Water Damage / Moisture 20 % LG Paderborn 1 S 72/22 North Rhine-Westphalia 06.03.2024 Moderate Badly soaked walls in an old building with salt efflorescence and crumbling plaster, even without mold Letter Noise 20 % AG Regensburg 4 C 275/91 Bavaria 16.04.1991 Moderate Construction noise from a large building site next door Letter Noise 20 % LG Dortmund 17 S 47/88 North Rhine-Westphalia 19.05.1988 Moderate Frequent loud parties at weekends until late at night Letter Noise 20 % AG Bremen 17 C 105/10 Bremen 09.03.2011 Moderate Recurring shouting and loud music from the neighboring apartment Letter Noise 20 % LG Berlin 67 S 162/16 Berlin 11.08.2016 Moderate Considerable noise from a hotel that opened in the building after the lease was signed Letter Noise 20 % AG Mitte 104 C 33/23 Berlin 01.02.2024 Moderate Construction noise from the neighboring plot; flat rate for the entire construction period Letter Power / Gas Outage 20 % LG Berlin 67 T 70/02 Berlin 18.08.2002 Moderate Landlord cut off water and gas; 20% for the missing water supply alone Letter Pests / Vermin 20 % AG Lahnstein 2 C 675/87 Rhineland-Palatinate 19.10.1987 Moderate 20–25 silverfish in the apartment, poison in the bedroom Letter Elevator 20 % AG Mitte 10 C 24/07 Berlin 19.04.2007 Severe Elevator out for 16 days; 10th floor (10. OG) of a high-rise Letter Other 20 % LG Kassel 1 S 274/84 Hesse 03.07.1987 Moderate Faulty seals on windows and doors; strong drafts and water getting in Letter Other 20 % AG Charlottenburg 239 C 196/17 Berlin 14.12.2017 Moderate Advertising banner on scaffolding covered 4 of 5 windows and the balcony Letter Other 20 % LG Berlin 18 S 133/15 Berlin 11.02.2016 Moderate Damaged and missing asbestos floor tiles (Floor-Flex); reduction from the start of the lease Letter Mold 15 % AG Saarbrücken 121 C 199/19 Saarland 31.01.2020 Moderate Several square meters of mold on the exterior wall above the window and along the skirting boards in the bedroom Letter Water Damage / Moisture 15 % AG Stuttgart 32 C 1562/19 Baden-Württemberg 14.02.2020 Minor Leaking shower cubicle, large amounts of water on the bathroom floor; plaster damage in the bedroom Letter Noise 15 % AG Köln 214 C 437/00 North Rhine-Westphalia 22.10.2001 Moderate Noise from a metal gate Letter Noise 15 % LG Berlin 65 S 111/22 Berlin 09.02.2023 Moderate Noise and dust from construction work on the neighboring plot; later 10% Letter Elevator 15 % AG Mitte 10 C 3/07 Berlin 03.05.2007 Moderate Elevator out for 16 days; 6th floor (6. OG) Letter Other 15 % AG Villingen-Schwenningen 11 C 243/14 Baden-Württemberg 03.09.2015 Moderate Leaky windows with drafts and heat loss Letter Other 15 % LG Berlin 64 S 223/17 Berlin 17.10.2018 Moderate Asbestos floor tiles (Floor-Flex) with many damaged spots that can release fibers Letter Other 12 % AG Tempelhof-Kreuzberg 8 C 186/17 Berlin 14.12.2017 Moderate After modernization, window areas a third smaller in four rooms; 3% per window Letter Mold 10 % AG Steinfurt 3 C 230/77 North Rhine-Westphalia 11.08.1977 Minor Mold on the exterior wall of a storage room Letter Mold 10 % AG Norderstedt 42 C 561/08 Schleswig-Holstein 18.12.2009 Minor Mold on window reveals in the children's room and bedroom caused by thermal bridges Letter Mold 10 % LG Berlin 65 S 400/15 Berlin 15.04.2016 Minor Airing the apartment six times a day to prevent mold is unreasonable for the tenant Letter Mold 10 % AG Tempelhof-Kreuzberg 20 C 234/13 Berlin 19.10.2015 Minor Airing 6 to 8 times a day to prevent mold is unreasonable Letter Mold 10 % AG Stuttgart 37 C 1506/19 Baden-Württemberg 09.02.2021 Minor Mold in the bedroom due to missing insulation of the top-floor ceiling Letter Heating / Hot Water 10 % AG Hamburg 49 C 836/86 Hamburg 08.01.1987 Minor Cracking and rushing noises from the heating Letter Heating / Hot Water 10 % AG Bremerhaven 59 C 1214/91 Bremen 26.05.1992 Minor Undersized radiator, only 18 °C in the kitchen Letter Heating / Hot Water 10 % AG Potsdam 23 C 236/10 Brandenburg 30.04.2012 Minor Room temperature repeatedly below 20 °C Letter Water Damage / Moisture 10 % AG Charlottenburg 210 C 375/17 Berlin 28.02.2018 Minor Leaking roof, water coming in until it was sealed Letter Noise 10 % LG Berlin 63 S 236/14 Berlin 06.02.2015 Moderate Constant noise from neighbors: arguing, shouting, banging, stomping, slamming doors Letter Noise 10 % LG Berlin 63 S 223/15 Berlin 15.04.2016 Minor Noise from the ventilation system of a shisha lounge on the ground floor Letter Power / Gas Outage 10 % AG Münster 7 C 4009/15 North Rhine-Westphalia 21.11.2017 Minor Brown water from several taps, cold water in the bathroom cannot be regulated Letter Power / Gas Outage 10 % LG Essen 10 S 43/16 North Rhine-Westphalia 21.07.2016 Minor Phone and internet connection dead for 14 months due to faulty in-house wiring Letter Power / Gas Outage 10 % AG Dortmund 425 C 5770/19 North Rhine-Westphalia 08.10.2019 Minor TV reception promised in the lease was discontinued Letter Pests / Vermin 10 % AG Bonn 6 C 277/84 North Rhine-Westphalia 08.02.1985 Minor Mice and cockroaches Letter Pests / Vermin 10 % AG Aachen 5 C 5/00 North Rhine-Westphalia 19.04.2000 Minor Rats in the courtyard behind the apartment Letter Pests / Vermin 10 % AG Rendsburg 3 C 551/87 Schleswig-Holstein 11.03.1988 Moderate Mouse plague in a rural area (15 mice caught every day) Letter Pests / Vermin 10 % AG Bad Säckingen C 368/75 Baden-Württemberg 30.03.1976 Moderate Mice in the apartment, droppings in dishes and pots Letter Elevator 10 % AG Charlottenburg 2 C 484/89 Berlin 15.12.1989 Moderate Elevator out of service, 4th floor (4. OG); shut down by the building authority Letter Elevator 10 % AG Mitte 10 C 104/19 Berlin 11.06.2020 Minor Elevator out of service since Aug 2019; 3rd floor (3. OG) Letter Other 10 % AG Frankfurt a.M. 33 C 1251/17 (76) Hesse 18.08.2017 Moderate Strong cold drafts from the ventilation system in a passive house Letter Other 10 % LG Berlin 65 S 296/10 Berlin 28.01.2011 Moderate Strong smell of decay and feces from the neighboring apartment Letter Heating / Hot Water 8 % AG Gießen 48 C 48/15 Hesse 05.11.2015 Minor Heating broken in one room Nov 2014 – May 2015; partial failure Letter Noise 8 % AG Wedding 9 C 46/16 Berlin 13.03.2017 Minor Noise from a neighboring refugee shelter in the summer months; balcony unusable Letter Other 8 % AG Tempelhof-Kreuzberg 24 C 19/21 Berlin 22.02.2022 Minor Pungent smell from a bakery on the ground floor in the mornings; later 5% Letter Noise 7.5 % AG Köpenick 4 C 116/10 Berlin 02.07.2010 Minor More traffic noise after the road was turned into a motorway feeder; up to 1,000 vehicles/hour Letter Power / Gas Outage 7.5 % AG Köln 206 C 251/94 North Rhine-Westphalia 24.04.1995 Minor No hot water between 10 pm and 7 am Letter Elevator 7.5 % AG Bremen-Blumenthal 10 C 300/86 Bremen 04.12.1986 Moderate 5th floor (5. OG), student residence, both elevators out of service Letter Elevator 7.5 % AG Schöneberg 15 C 208/17 Berlin 20.11.2018 Minor Elevator broken for several months after the basement flooded; apartment on the 3rd floor (3. OG) Letter Mold 7 % AG Köln 222 C 25/10 North Rhine-Westphalia 21.07.2011 Minor Black mold on the silicone joints of the windows Letter Noise 7 % AG Hamburg 43 C 268/74 Hamburg 24.01.1975 Minor Noise from a laundromat in the building Letter Heating / Hot Water 5 % LG Berlin 63 S 423/11 Berlin 08.06.2012 Minor Temperature regularly only 19 °C Letter Water Damage / Moisture 5 % LG Kleve 6 S 285/90 North Rhine-Westphalia 05.02.1991 Minor Discolored tiles after a repair Letter Water Damage / Moisture 5 % AG Lichtenberg 10 C 111/24 Berlin 06.03.2025 Minor Cellar included in the lease flooded by a burst pipe and unusable Letter Noise 5 % AG Frankfurt a.M. 33 C 1726/04-13 Hesse 15.04.2005 Minor Noise from youth football with loud shouting Letter Power / Gas Outage 5 % AG Mitte 7 C 82/17 Berlin 25.04.2018 Minor New building: hot water reaches 55 °C only after 65 seconds (DIN 1988-200) Letter Power / Gas Outage 5 % AG Brandenburg a.d. Havel 31 C 210/21 Brandenburg 13.02.2023 Minor Hot water reaches 40 °C only after about 50 seconds and never reaches 55 °C Letter Pests / Vermin 5 % AG Köln 201 C 254/05 North Rhine-Westphalia 27.06.2006 Minor Silverfish for at least a year in the living rooms, kitchen and hallway Letter Other 5 % AG Schöneberg 13 C 129/20 Berlin 11.02.2021 Minor Less daylight after modernization due to insulation, smaller windows and a balcony above Letter Other 4.8 % BGH VIII ZR 51/20 12.10.2021 Minor Bicycle cellar reduced from 49 to 7 m² by modernization (rate of the lower court upheld) Letter Elevator 4.5 % AG Nürnberg 28 C 4478/12 Bavaria 24.10.2012 Minor Elevator broken since 2009; tenant on the 2nd floor (2. OG) Letter Other 4 % AG Gießen 48 C 48/15 Hesse 05.11.2015 Minor Persistent bad smell in the stairwell Letter Power / Gas Outage 3.5 % LG Berlin 67 S 26/07 Berlin 02.06.2008 Minor Hot water at 40 °C only after a long run-off time Letter Elevator 3 % AG Tempelhof-Kreuzberg 2 C 207/13 Berlin 15.01.2014 Minor Elevator out of service, 2nd floor (2. OG) Letter Other 2 % LG Berlin 64 S 356/98 Berlin 16.02.1999 Minor Intercom does not work Letter